Famous lateral thinking puzzles, with answers

Published 8 min read

In short

A lateral thinking puzzle describes a strange scene in one sentence; you solve it by asking yes/no questions to the one player who knows the story. The three most famous are the man found dead in a field (with an unopened package), the naked man in the desert (holding a broken match) and albatross soup. Here are the 10 classics, with two questions to get each game going, and their answers at the bottom of the page.

Someone just hit you with "the man found dead in a field" and you want the answer. Or you're planning a game night and need riddles that always land. Here are the 10 lateral thinking classics, retold in our own words, each with two questions to get the game moving. The answers are grouped at the bottom of the page, so you don't read one by accident.

How to play these puzzles

One person reads the puzzle and its answer, then becomes the Keeper: nobody else knows the story. Everyone else asks yes/no questions, and the Keeper only answers yes, no or doesn't matter. The game ends when the table has rebuilt the story, or gives up.

That's how every situation puzzle works. The term lateral thinking was coined by Edward de Bono in the late 1960s, and Paul Sloane's Lateral Thinking Puzzlers (1992) helped bring the genre to print (per Wikipedia). The puzzles themselves have no known author: what follows is the most common version of each.

The two questions under each puzzle are the ones that unstick a table going in circles. The Keeper can drop them as hints or hold them back. Tip: if the Keeper reads the answer on a phone, there's nothing to memorize.

A heads-up before you start: two of these puzzles involve suicide (the hanging man and albatross soup). They're flagged; skip them if the subject is close to home.

The "man found dead" puzzles

These are the best known. Each starts with a body and one detail that doesn't fit.

The man found dead in a field

A man is found dead in the middle of a field. Next to him lies a package he never opened. There's nobody around, and no footprints lead to him.

  • "Does the package have anything to do with his death?" Yes.
  • "Did he walk into the field?" No.

See the answer

There's another death in a field that actually happened: a man dies in the middle of a cucumber field. It has nothing to do with the classic.

The naked man in the desert

A man is found dead and naked in the middle of the desert. In his hand, he's clutching half of a broken match.

  • "Were other people with him shortly before he died?" Yes.
  • "Did he get there by air?" Yes.

See the answer

The man hanging in an empty room (suicide)

A man is found hanging from the ceiling of a room locked from the inside. His feet are well off the floor. There's no furniture, nothing to climb on. Under him, a puddle of water.

  • "Was the puddle there when he hanged himself?" No.
  • "Did he stand on something?" Yes.

See the answer

The man found dead with 53 bicycles

A man is found shot dead. Around him are 53 bicycles.

  • "Are the bicycles actual bikes?" No.
  • "Was he playing a game when he died?" Yes.

See the answer

Everyday puzzles

Nobody dies in most of these. They're lighter, and perfect for introducing a group to the game.

The man who asks for a glass of water

A man walks into a bar and asks for a glass of water. The bartender pulls out a gun and points it at him. The man says thank you and leaves, happy.

  • "Was the man thirsty?" No.
  • "Did the bartender do him a favor?" Yes.

See the answer

The man who stops at the 7th floor

A man lives on the 10th floor. Every morning he takes the elevator down to the lobby. Every evening he takes it to the 7th floor and walks the last three flights. On rainy days, he rides all the way to the 10th.

  • "Does he walk for the exercise?" No.
  • "Does it have to do with his body?" Yes.

See the answer

The two iced drinks

Two friends order the same iced drink. The first gulps hers down and leaves. The second sips hers for an hour. The second one dies of poisoning; the first is fine.

  • "Was the poison in the drink itself?" No.
  • "Does the time they took to drink matter?" Yes.

See the answer

The man who pushes his car to a hotel

A man pushes his car up to a hotel. When he gets there, he knows he's bankrupt.

  • "Has his car broken down?" No.
  • "Is he playing a game?" Yes.

See the answer

Romeo and Juliet

Romeo and Juliet are found dead on the floor of a room. Around them are water and shards of glass. The window is open.

  • "Are Romeo and Juliet human?" No.
  • "Did the glass hold the water?" Yes.

See the answer

The most famous: albatross soup (suicide)

This is the best-known lateral thinking puzzle of all, also told with a seagull or a turtle: the albatross soup riddle. It takes a while to crack, because the answer is a whole backstory the table has to rebuild.

A man walks into a seaside restaurant and orders albatross soup. He takes one spoonful, puts the spoon down, walks out and takes his own life.

  • "Was the soup poisoned?" No.
  • "Was he ever shipwrecked?" Yes.

See the answer

The same game, with true stories

The puzzles above are made up. The ones in The Hidden Side are drawn from real events: news stories, or deaths recorded by historians. They play exactly the same way. On top of the cucumber field above, here are three more, shown without their solution:

In the app, the Keeper reads the solution on the phone, ticks off what the table finds and counts the questions; the full story appears at the end. More are featured in the riddles on this site, and the apps that play the same way are compared in Games like Black Stories: yes/no riddle apps compared.

The answers

Read only the one you came for: the others are right below it.

Answer: the man found dead in a field

The package is a parachute that failed to open. He jumped from a plane and hit the ground in the middle of the field, which is why there are no footprints.

Answer: the naked man in the desert

He was in a hot-air balloon with other passengers. The balloon was losing height, so they threw out everything they could, clothes included. It wasn't enough, so they drew matches to decide who would jump. He drew the broken one.

Answer: the man hanging in an empty room

He stood on a large block of ice to hang himself. The ice melted afterwards, leaving only the puddle.

Answer: the man found dead with 53 bicycles

The "bicycles" are Bicycle-brand playing cards. A deck has 52: the 53rd proved he was cheating, and the other players shot him.

Answer: the man who asks for a glass of water

He had hiccups and wanted water to get rid of them. The bartender understood and scared him with the gun instead: the hiccups stopped, and he no longer needed the water.

Answer: the man who stops at the 7th floor

He's very short and can only reach the button for the 7th floor. On rainy days he has his umbrella, and uses it to press the button for the 10th.

Answer: the two iced drinks

The poison was in the ice cubes. The first friend finished before they melted; the second gave the poison time to seep into her drink.

Answer: the man who pushes his car to a hotel

He's playing Monopoly. His token, the car, lands on a square where another player has built a hotel, and he can't pay the rent.

Answer: Romeo and Juliet

Romeo and Juliet are two goldfish. Their bowl was knocked over (by a cat, or by the wind through the open window) and shattered on the floor.

Answer: albatross soup

Years earlier, he was shipwrecked with his partner and other passengers. She died, and to keep him alive, the other survivors fed him what they called "albatross soup". At the restaurant, real albatross soup tastes different: he realizes what he was actually given back then. The details vary from version to version; the core of the story doesn't.

Frequently asked questions

What is the answer to the man found dead in a field riddle?

The unopened package next to him is a parachute that didn't open. He jumped from a plane and fell into the middle of the field, which is why no footprints lead to his body. The question that most often cracks it is "Did he walk into the field?", because the answer, no, points the table toward the sky.

What is the most famous lateral thinking puzzle?

Albatross soup, also told with a seagull or a turtle. A man tastes a soup in a restaurant, then takes his own life. Its answer is a whole backstory, which makes it slow to solve. The man found dead in a field and the naked man in the desert are the other two big classics of the genre.

What is a lateral thinking puzzle?

It's a strange scene described in one sentence, which you solve by asking questions that can be answered yes or no. One player knows the story; the others rebuild it. It's also called a situation puzzle, a yes/no puzzle, or in Japan and China, turtle soup. The Black Stories card game is built on the same idea.

Are these lateral thinking puzzles true stories?

No. The classics on this page are made up and circulate in several versions, with no known author. If you want puzzles of the same kind drawn from real events, all 60 stories in The Hidden Side are, and four of them are listed above, without their solution.

How many questions does it take to solve a lateral thinking puzzle?

It mostly depends on the group. Players who know the genre get there fast; a table of beginners can circle a false lead for a long time. There's no standard number. To keep the pace up, the Keeper can drop a hint question, or set a question limit before you start.

Situation puzzleLateral thinkingKeeperYes/no questionDoesn't matterAlbatross soup riddle

Read next

Énigmes de pensée latérale célèbres (avec réponses)

Try The Hidden Side

The riddle game where every story is true.